corner graphic   Hi,    
ver. 2.0.20.05.29
Finding the new version too difficult to understand? Go to classic.studylight.org/

Bible Commentaries

Expository Notes of Dr. Thomas Constable
Job 31

 

 

Verses 1-40

Job"s continuing innocence ch31

As was common in ancient Near Eastern judicial cases, Job concluded his summary defense with an oath of innocence. He did so in the form of a negative confession complete with self-imprecations. [Note: Parsons, p141. Cf. Michael Brennan Dick, "The Legal Metaphor in Job 31 ," Catholic Biblical Quarterly41 (1979):42 , 47.] He concluded with a challenge to God to present His charges in writing ( Job 31:35-37). Job"s idea was that if God remained silent this would be a vindication of his innocence. However, if he had been guilty, God would have to intervene and impose the punishment Job had designated. [Note: Norman C. Habel, The Book of Job , p164.] Note the frequent repetition of the phrase, "If I have . . ." and its equivalents.

"Chapter31as to its literary format is a negative testament by which Job will close the matter of whether he is being punished for his sins. After such a statement, in the jurisprudence of the ancient Near East, the burden of proof fell on the court. That is why Job 31:40 says, "The words of Job are ended." Each disavowal had to be accompanied by an oath that called for the same punishment the offense deserved on the basis of the principle of lex talionis ( Job 31:5-10). Because the charges against Job were wide and varied, he must give a similarly wide disavowal. He had already done this in a general way (cf. Job 23:10-12), but now he specifies and calls for condemnation and punishment from both God and man ( Job 31:8; Job 31:11-12; Job 31:14; Job 31:22-23) if he is guilty of any of these sins." [Note: Smick, "Architectonics, Structured . . .," p94. Cf. Hartley, p406.]

Job claimed purity from ethical defilement in two ways. He referred to the binding covenant he had made with his eyes ( Job 31:1). Then he used the oath form "if" such and such be true "then" (sometimes not stated) let thus and so happen ( Job 31:5-10; Job 31:13; Job 31:16; Job 31:19-20 [twice], 21-22 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 38 , 39-40).

"The making of a covenant with his eyes is not merely a promise not to lust after a girl. The sin he has in mind is far more fundamental, or it would not have commanded this position in the poem. Job is emphatically denying an insidious and widespread form of idolatry: devotion to the betula, "the maiden," the goddess of fertility. This Venus of the Semitic world was variously known as the Maiden Anat in Ugaritic, Ashtoreth in preexilic Israel, and Ishtar in Babylonian sources, wherein she is described as "laden with vitality, charm and voluptuousness." She is probably the "Queen of Heaven" mentioned in Jeremiah 7:18; Jeremiah 44:16-19." [Note: Smick, "Architectonics, Structured . . .," p96.]

Most of the14sins that Job mentioned in this chapter were not heinous crimes but relatively minor deviations from the ethical ideal. They were covert rather than overt iniquities. Thus Job claimed innocence on the highest level of morality (cf. Matthew 5:27-28). Note also that he continued to assume that God punishes the wicked ( Job 31:2-3).

"As a consequence of his suffering, Job viewed man"s relationship to God as being based on God"s sovereign caprice; therefore man could hope for happiness only by adhering to an ethical rightness superior to God"s whereby he could demand vindication ( Job 31; cf. Job 35:2 b)." [Note: Parsons, p144.]

Job 31:10 has in view Job"s wife grinding corn with a hard millstone, the work of a slave, and being overpowered by men sexually.

"His hypothetical adultery would in Hebrew eyes be an offence against her husband, and so another"s adultery with his wife would be a similar offence against him. In Hebrew law adultery always involved a married woman. The marital state of the man was immaterial." [Note: Rowley, p200.]

Fundamentally, adultery involves a married man or a married woman (cf. Leviticus 20:10), but in Israel, as well as in Roman society, infidelity by the husband was not commonly viewed as constituting adultery. [Note: See Unger"s Bible Dictionary, 1957 ed, s.v. "Adultery."] Job"s words about adultery ( Job 31:9-12) are classic and reveal righteous abhorrence of that sin. Likewise, his statements regarding the importance of treating slaves as human beings ( Job 31:13-15) reveal Job"s fear of God and love for his fellowman. He respected human life highly ( Job 31:16-23). Job further claimed that he was not an idolater ( Job 31:24-28), selfish ( Job 31:29-32), or hypocritical ( Job 31:33-34).

"Here then is either a very clean conscience or a very calloused one." [Note: Andersen, p244.]

Job"s cry for a hearer of his claims ( Job 31:35) probably implied God rather than the mediator he had requested earlier ( Job 16:19; Job 19:25; cf. Job 30:20).

"An examination of biblical and extra-biblical legal documents establishes Job 31:35 as a dependent"s official appeal before a third party for a civil hearing at which the judge would compel the plaintiff to formalize his accusations and to present any supporting evidence. As we shall see, this request was ordinarily made only after all attempts at informal arbitration had been exhausted and was often accompanied by a sworn statement of innocence. In Job 31the oath of innocence has been expanded to embrace the entire chapter." [Note: Dick, p38.]

His "adversary" in this verse was also God (cf. Job 13:24; Job 16:9; Job 19:11). We should probably understand "owners" ( Job 31:39) as "workers."

Having ended his final summation in defense of his innocence, Job rested his case and waited for God"s verdict. This is another climax in the book. Job had claimed innocence in his personal life ( Job 31:1-12), toward his neighbor ( Job 31:13-20), and toward God ( Job 31:24-34; cf. Job 1:11). Job"s friends believed that God always punishes sin, therefore Job was a sinner. Job believed that God was punishing him when he was innocent, therefore God was unfair.

 


Copyright Statement
These files are public domain.
Text Courtesy of BibleSupport.com. Used by Permission.

Bibliography Information
Constable, Thomas. DD. "Commentary on Job 31:4". "Expository Notes of Dr. Thomas Constable". https://www.studylight.org/commentaries/dcc/job-31.html. 2012.

Lectionary Calendar
Friday, May 29th, 2020
the Seventh Week after Easter
ADVERTISEMENT
Commentary Navigator
Search This Commentary
Enter query in the box below
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
To report dead links, typos, or html errors or suggestions about making these resources more useful use our convenient contact form
Powered by Lightspeed Technology