Lectionary Calendar
Friday, March 1st, 2024
the Second Week of Lent
There are 30 days til Easter!
Partner with StudyLight.org as God uses us to make a difference for those displaced by Russia's war on Ukraine.
Click to donate today!

Bible Commentaries
Luke 17

Alford's Greek Testament Critical Exegetical CommentaryAlford's Greek Testament Commentary

Search for…
Enter query below:
Additional Authors

Verse 1

1. ] τὰ σκ . is perhaps owing to some offence which had happened; the departure of the Pharisees in disgust, or some point in their conduct; such as the previous chapter alluded to.

ἀνένδεκτόν ἐστιν = οὐκ ἐνδέχεται , ch. Luke 13:33 .

Verses 1-10

1 10. ] FURTHER DISCOURSES. The discourse appears to proceed onward from the foregoing.

Verse 2

2. ] See Matthew 18:6-7 , and notes.

τῶν μικ . τ ., perhaps the publicans and sinners of ch. Luke 15:1 ; perhaps also, repeated with reference to what took place, Matt. l. c.

Verses 3-4

3, 4. ] See on Matthew 18:15 ; Matthew 18:21-22 .

The προσέχετε ἑαυτ . here is to warn them not to be too readily dismayed at σκάνδαλα , nor to meet them in a brother with an unforgiving spirit.

ἐπιτίμ . ] ‘ ἀγάπη begins with ἀληθεύειν ,’ Stier: who remarks, that in the Church, as in the world, the love of many waxing cold, not being strong or warm enough for this ἐπιτίμησον , is the cause why offences abound.

Verse 5

5. ] πρόσθ . ἡμ . πίστ ., increase our faith ,’ of the E. V., is not exact: give us more faith, is more literal and simpler. Wordsw.’s rendering, “Give faith in addition to our other privileges, powers, and virtues,” is not so probable, seeing 1) that faith is not the crowning item in such a list, but the first and most elementary: and 2) that, had this been intended, it would most probably have been expressed πρόσθ . ἡμῖν καὶ πίστιν .

This is the only example in the Gospels in which the Apostles are marked out as requesting or saying any thing to the Lord. They are amazed at the greatness of the faith which is to overcome σκάνδαλα and forgive ἁμαρτήματα as in Luke 17:3-4 : and pray that more faith may be added to them.

Verse 6

6. ] See on Matt. ( Luk 17:20 ) Luke 21:21 . On this occasion some particular tree of the sort was close at hand, and furnished the instance, just as the Mount of Transfiguration in the former of those passages, and the Mount of Olives in the latter.

συκάμινος is the mulberry-tree; not very common in Palestine, but still found there. It must not be confounded with συκομορέα , ch. Luke 19:4 , which is the Egyptian fig. See note there.

Notice the different tenses with ἄν : ἐλέγετε ἄν , ye would say: ὑπήκουσεν ἄν , it would (even while you were speaking) have obeyed .

ἐκριζώθ . ] ‘Cum ipsis radicibus, in mari mansura. Tale quiddam fit ipsis fidelibus.’ Bengel.

Verse 7

7. ] εὐθέως in the E. V. is wrongly joined with ἐρεῖ : it corresponds to μετὰ ταῦτα in Luke 17:8 . ‘Construendum; cito accumbe: cito cupiunt accumbere qui missis cæteris officiis fidem sibi summam conferri oportere putant.’ Bengel.

Verses 7-10

7 10. ] The connexion is, ‘Ye are servants of your Master; and therefore endurance is required of you, faith and trust to endure out your day’s work before you enter into your rest. Your Master will enter into His, but your time will not yet come; and all the service which you can meanwhile do Him, is but that which is your bounden duty to do, seeing that your body, soul, and spirit are His.’

Verse 8

8. ] ἕως φ . κ . π ., till I shall have eaten and drunken: see ch. Luke 12:37 , where a different assurance seems to be given. But our Lord is here speaking of what we in our state of service are to expect; there, of what in our state of manumission (‘mensæ servos adhibere manumissionis erat species.’ Grotius, citing from Ulpian) and adoption , the wonders of His grace will confer on us . Here the question is of right; there, of favour .

Verse 9

9. ] Our Lord is not laying down rules for the behaviour of an earthly master to his servants, but (see above) is speaking of the rightful state of relation between us, and Him whose we are, and whom we serve .

Verse 10

10. ] This shews the sense of the parable, as applying to our own thoughts of ourselves, and the impossibility of any claim for our services to God.

In Romans 6:23 (see also the foregoing verses) we have the true ground on which we look for eternal life set before us; viz. as the gift of God whose servants we are , not the wages , as in the case of sin, whose we are not . In the case of men this is different; a good servant is εὔχρηστος ( Phm 1:11 ), not ἀχρεῖος , i.e. οὗ μὴ ἔχει τις χρείαν , Etym. Mag. See Acts 17:25 .

The case supposed introduces an argument à fortiori: ‘ how much more, when ye have failed in so many respects .’ ‘Miser est quem Dominus servum inutilem appellat, Matthew 25:30 ; beatus qui se ipse.’ Bengel.

Thus closes the series of discourses which began with ch. Luke 15:1 .

Verses 11-19

11 19. ] HEALING OF TEN LEPERS. It does not appear to what part of the last journey this is to be referred. There is no reason for supposing it to have been subsequent to what has just been related: this is not implied. It may have been at the very beginning of the journey. From the circumstance that these lepers were a mixed company of Jews and Samaritans, διὰ μέσον Σ . κ . Γ . probably means ‘ between Samaria and Galilee,’ on the frontiers of both. Meyer supposes αὐτός to mean ‘He for his part’ separate from the others going up to the feast, who would go direct through Samaria. Xen. has διὰ μέσου δὲ ῥεῖ τούτων ποταμός , i.e. ‘ between these walls.’ Anab. i. 4. 4.

This seems to be [101] with Matthew 19:1 . The journey mentioned there would lead Him διὰ μέσ . Σ . κ . Γ .

[101] When, in the Gospels, and in the Evangelic statement, 1 Corinthians 11:23-25 , the sign (║) occurs in a reference, it is signified that the word occurs in the parallel place in the other Gospels, which will always be found indicated at the head of the note on the paragraph. When the sign (║) is qualified , thus, ‘║ Mk.,’ or ‘║ Mt. Mk.,’ &c., it is signified that the word occurs in the parallel place in that Gospel or Gospels, but not in the other or others .

Verse 12

12. πόῤῥωθεν ] See Leviticus 13:46 ; Numbers 5:2 . The Rabbinical prescriptions as to the distance are given in Wetstein.

Their misery had broken down the national distinction, and united them in one company.

On the nature of leprosy and its significance, see on Matthew 8:2 .

Verse 14

14. ] One of our Lord’s first miracles had been the healing of a leper; then He touched him and said, ‘Be thou clean:’ now He sinks as it were the healing , and keeps it in the background; and why so? There may have been reasons unknown to us; but one we can plainly see, and that is, to bring out for the Church the lesson which the history yields. In their going away, in the absence of Jesus they are healed: what need to go back and give Him thanks? Here was a trial of their love: faith they had, enough to go, and enough to be cleansed: but love (with the one exception) gratitude, they had not.

ἐπιδείξ . ] See note on Matthew 8:4 .

ἐν τῷ ὑπ . αὐτ . ] i.e. while on their way; the meaning evidently being that they had not gone far, and that the whole took place within a short time. They had not been to the priests, as some suppose.

Verse 15

15. ] The ἰδὼν ὅτι ἰάθη , and ὑπέστ . μ . φ . μεγ . δ . τ . θεόν , set before us something immediate, and, I should be inclined to think, witnessed by the narrator.

Verse 16

16. αὐτ . ἦν Σαμ . ] Strauss supposes (and Hase, but doubtfully) from this, that the whole narrative arose out of a parable about Jews and Samaritans. Such an absurd notion is however not without its use for believers. Every miracle is a parable: our Lord did not work mere feats of supernatural power, but preached by His miracles as well as by His discourses.

Verse 17

17. ] Were not the ten cleansed? but (of those ten) the nine, where (are they) ?

Verse 18

18. ὁ ἀλλογ . οὗτ . ] The Samaritans were Gentiles; not a mixed race , as is sometimes erroneously supposed. They had a mixed religion , but were themselves originally from other countries: see 2 Kings 17:24-41 . There may have been a reason for the nine Jews not returning, that they held the ceremonial duty imposed on them to be paramount, which the Samaritan might not rate so highly. That he was going to Mount Gerizim does not appear: from his being found with Jews, he probably would act as a Jew.

Verse 19

19. ] σέσωκέν σε in a higher sense than the mere cleansing of his leprosy theirs was merely the beholding of the brazen serpent with the outward eyes, but his, with the eye of inward faith; and this faith saved him; not only healed his body, but his soul.

Verse 20

20. ] The question certainly is asked by the Pharisees, as all their questions were asked, with no good end in view: to entangle our Lord, or draw from Him some direct announcement which might be matter of accusation.

μετὰ παρατηρ . ] with (accompanied with) anticipation, or observation. The cognate verb is used ch. Luk 14:1 of the Pharisees ‘watching’ Jesus.

Verses 20-37

20 37. ] PROPHETIC ANSWER TO THE PHARISEES. In this discourse we have several sayings which our Lord afterwards repeated in His last prophetic discourse to the four apostles on Mount Olivet; but much also which is peculiar to Luke, and most precious ( eine kostliche Perle , De Wette).

Verse 21

21. οὐδὲ ἐρ .… ] Its coming shall be so gradual and unobserved, that none during its waxing onward shall be able to point here or there for a proof of its coming.

ἰδοὺ γάρ ] for behold the kingdom of God is (already) among you. The misunderstanding which rendered these words ‘ within you ,’ meaning this in a spiritual sense, ‘ in your hearts ,’ should have been prevented by reflecting that they are addressed to the Pharisees , in whose hearts it certainly was not. Nor could the expression in this connexion well bear this spiritual meaning potentially i.e. is in its nature, within your hearts. The words are too express and emphatic for this. We have the very expression, Xen. Anab. i. 10. 3, ἀλλὰ καὶ ταύτην ἔσωσαν ( οἱ Ἕλληνες ) καὶ ἄλλα ὁπόσα ἐντὸς αὐτῶν καὶ χρήματα καὶ ἄνθρωποι ἐγένοντο πάντα ἔσωσαν : see also John 1:26 ; John 12:35 , both of which are analogous expressions. See the two renderings compared in Bleek’s note.

The kingdom of God was begun among them , and continues thus making its way in the world, without observation of men; so that whenever men can say ‘lo here or lo there,’ whenever great ‘revivals’ or ‘triumphs of the faith’ can be pointed to, they stand self-condemned as not belonging to that kingdom . Thus we see that every such marked event in the history of the Church is by God’s own hand as it were blotted and marred , so as not to deceive us into thinking that the kingdom has come. So it was at the Pentecostal era: so at that of Constantine; so at the Reformation.

The meaning ‘among you,’ includes of course the deeper and personal one ‘within each of you,’ but the two are not convertible.

Verse 22

22. ] This saying is taken up from ἐντὸς ὑμῶν ἐστίν . ‘ He is among you, who is the Bridegroom , the Son of Man; ’ during whose presence ye cannot mourn, but when He shall be taken from you, you shall wish in vain for one of these days of His presence.

Stier (iii. 362) thinks this addressed to the Pharisees also, and to apply to their recognizing too late in their future misery the Messiahship of Jesus: but this does not appear from the text.

Meyer tries to prove this interpretation altogether wrong, from the ἐν τ . ἡμέραις τ . υἱ . τ . ἀνθ ., Luke 17:26 . But the words have the general meaning of the days of the Son of Man’s presence , and this extends on to His future presence, or παρουσία , as well. Of course, if they hereafter desired to see one of the days of His presence, it would be a second or future presence.

Verse 23

23. καὶ ἐρ . ὑμ . ] ‘Ye shall not see one; therefore do not run after false reports of my coming.’ A warning to all so-called expositors, and followers of expositors, of prophecy, who cry ἰδοὺ ἐκεῖ and ἰδοὺ ὧδε , every time that war breaks out, or revolutions occur.

See on these verses, 23, 24, Mat 24:23-27 and notes.

Verse 24

24. ἐκ τῆς εἰς τὴν ] Supply χώρας … χώραν .

Verses 25-30

25 30. ] The events which must precede the coming: and (1) Luke 17:25 , as regards the Lord Himself , His sufferings and rejection, primarily by this generation, but in implication, by the world; and (2) Luke 17:26-30 , which unfold this implication as regards the whole world, which shall be in its state of carelessness and sensuality at that time: see notes on Matthew 24:37-39 . The example of the days of Lot is added here, and thereby the sanction of the Lord of Truth given to another part of the sacred record, on which modern scepticism has laid its unhallowed hands.

Verse 28

28. ] Bornemann joins ὁμοίως with the former verse but thus the parallelism (see Luke 17:29 , end) is broken.

Verse 29

29. ] ἔβρεξεν , impersonal, not ὁ θεὸς ἔβρ . That such an expression as ὁ θεὸς βρέχει is used Matthew 5:45 , is no proof that when βρέχει is used impersonally the sacred name is to be supplied.

Luk 17:31 refers immediately to the example of Sodom just related. In Mat 24:16-18 it finds its place by a reference to the destruction of Jerusalem, see there.

Verse 32

32. ] A solemn caution is here added, binding the warning to the example before, μὴ ἐπιστρεψάτω remember her who did .

Verse 33

33. ] See on Matthew 10:39 , and ch. Luke 9:24 . In connexion here, it leads the way to Luke 17:34-35 .

ζητήσῃ should be rendered as a futurus exactus , as an aorist conjoined with a future always must be: shall have sought, i.e. ‘during his preceding life,’ shall lose it then .

ζωογονήσει , vivipariet ( Act 7:19 ): an expressive word, derived from animal parturition, bringing forth to air and life what was before concealed in the womb. That day shall come as the pains of labour ( ὠδῖνες ) on a woman in travail ( Mat 24:8 ): but to the saints of God it shall be the birth of the soul and body to life and glory everlasting. See St. Ignatius ad Rom. c. 6.” Wordsw.

Verses 34-36

34 36. ] See on Matthew 24:40-41 . Here, there are two references: (1) to the servants of the Lord in the midst of the world out of which they shall be separated: (2) to the separation of the faithful and unfaithful among themselves .

Luk 17:34 indicates a closer relationship than that of mere fellow-workmen, and sets forth the division of even families in that day.

Verse 37

37. ] ποῦ , not ‘ how? ’ (Kuinoel) but literal where shall this happen? The disciples know not the universality of this which our Lord is announcing to them, and which His dark and awful saying proclaims, see note on it, Matthew 24:28 .

Observe, there is not a word , except so far as the greater coming includes the lesser, in all this, of the destruction of Jerusalem. The future παρουσία of the Lord is the only subject: and thus it is an entirely distinct discourse from that in Matthew 24:0 , or our ch. 21.

Bibliographical Information
Alford, Henry. "Commentary on Luke 17". Alford's Greek Testament Critical Exegetical Commentary. https://www.studylight.org/commentaries/eng/hac/luke-17.html. 1863-1878.
adsFree icon
Ads FreeProfile